Tuesday, February 10, 2009

The Forum Liberalis

Uh oh, GWLANA, I broke the rules... again!

So. I made of the mistake of not just blogging about Rav but actually going in there and once again got sucked into the psychotic world of hyperliberalism that honestly must make Baby Jesus cry.

As I said to Amanda, most of the people in there are so liberal they don’t even tell THEMSELVES the truth about their own issues for fear of offending their own self-worth. For the most part, they are just tiptoeing around, apologizing and smiling at each other. There is nothing more irritating to me than people who dance around topics and use "gentle" language for fear of offending any number of groups (for example, it's not unusual to hear someone respond to a question about submission like this: "Well, I don't want to exclude transgender marriages from my assessment, but....") If you should happen to make a comment about the fact that gender roles are not a figment of the imagination, they start telling you how you must then logically assign roles to members of other races and be a total racist crapbag. Right. They are big on not excluding anyone, but they arent' ashamed to say that they they would like to exclude the Christian right from anything and everything... to include the right to breathe the oxygen we all must share. This type of Political Correctness is not only nauseating, it's destructive. There are only so many people you can "include" before society begins to disintegrate. What liberals have never understood is that we do things for the good of the majority, that's the only way a society can work. Does that mean that we exclude or marginalize anyone? Absolutely not. What it does mean, though, is that we expect everyone to do their part and pull their load.

This is why it's funny when liberals tell me they "don't like the army." Oh boo hoo. The army loves you, baby. While they sit around whining about how unfair and mean the army is, the army provides them and the whole world with security that gives them the freedom TO complain about itself. Now THAT'S a sense of national duty. Recently, we got into a conversation about how harsh the army's policies about mental illness are. Are they? Sure. They could probably be more sensitive and helpful for those who truly ARE struggling with things like PTSD. One need only look at the numerous soldier suicides this year to determine that. But what do people expect them to do? To pass out candy and sing kumbaya around a camp fire? To send soldiers on vacation? It's the army. It didn't become the most powerful army in the world by sitting around being sensitive to people's needs. In case no one noticed, there's a war going on. The army itself knows the truth--- they sing it in cadence every morning. Their job is battle. They'll rest when they're dead.

Talking to people this liberal, for me, is like talking to an invading alien army. I am not equipped with the correct vocal chords to communicate. Even if I was, I would not be equipped with knowledge of their language. And since they are hostile, I have no desire to even attempt it, it's far easier and safer for the defense of my planet to just blast an RPG into the herd, pray that it hits a target somewhere near the center, and run for your life. When they retaliate with what THEY claim is "just friendly fire," your only option is to find the nearest nuclear bomb and let it roll. This is the verbal equivalent of my tactics whenever I go in there.

The problem I have with rav is this. I was raised in France and in California, where we often have what's called a "Cafe Philo." A bunch of people sit around a table drinking coffee and discussing life. Sometimes, it gets heated. Other times not. But it's always fruitful to see people from all walks of life getting together to discuss the important issues. This is what a forum is.
The dictionary definition is: A medium of open discussion or voicing of ideas.

I was not on the debate team when I was in high school. I thought they were huge geeks. Instead, I snuck out of fourth period math and met with my friends at the coffee shop, where we smoked cigarettes and sipped organic soy chais and chatted about the meaning of life. This is the way it has always been in my world.
So why, then, does Ravelry seem to think that life operates like a debate team? That in order to participate in their forums, of which they persist in creating subforums and further subforums to continue to isolate me from speaking about religion "as a way of life." (yes, even in the DISCUSSIONS ABOUT RELIGION forum!)we must somehow excel at professional debate?

Instead of being able to go in there, share your life experience, and read the life experience of others, hear, learn, grow, and think, we are required to read endless amounts of "statistics" and "facts" and babblings of people with PhD's. We are required, if we want to have an opinion, to back it up with data. Why??

Perhaps it's because I have absolutely no respect for "education" as it is, but this really bothers me. Obama is educated. I think he's a moron. My husband was not. I think he's a genius. It really doesn't matter to me if some institution or organization has given you a stamp of approval and said "we endorse this person as telling the truth." The only qualifying factor, for me, that makes a person worthy of having an opinion that I will count as "fact" is one who knows the Bible, truly knows the Bible, as one who is illuminated by the Holy Spirit of God. I could not care less if you spent 22 years furthering your studies at I'm Special U. It really has no bearing on how much you know, for scripture says "The wisdom of this world is passing."
NOW, this doesn't mean that I believe we need to throw knowledge out. Knowledge is good, and faith is not, nor has it ever been, in opposition to science. Science will never disprove God, nor will it prove Him ,because we are simply called to live in faith. Those of us who do will find God all around us, and no amount of "scientific proof" would convince us otherwise. Nevertheless we have the responsibility to make ourselves understood. To communicate in a language that the listener can hear. I am the first person to admit that this becomes increasingly taxing as time goes by, particularly when you are faced with the same questions, the same responses, and the same people, day in and day out. It becomes so taxing, in fact, that I have been guilty (and was last night) of throwing my hands up and saying: "you know what? Screw it. You really aren't important enough for me to even bother trying to communicate truth to you. Just wallow in your life and you'll have a nice big surprise at the end."

Unfortunately for me, that's the wrong answer. I am not able to do that because I am called to care about these people--- to love every one of them, heretical, nasty, vile morality, and all.

The problem I have in online forums is that each one takes on the characteristics of the people who frequent it most. I love the R&P because I've been there the longest, and I set the tone, and I know anything goes, and I know not to be offended and I know no one else will be either. The R&P, for me, is far superior to any forum I've ever encountered because it's the most like a Cafe Philo. We go in, we relax, we talk about the issues, we poke fun at each other, and we grow. I've done some of my best growing in the R&P. Not everyone shares my beliefs in there, but at least there are enough people with similar beliefs that make you seem like a person with a right to an opinion, as opposed to feeling like everyone's watching you like you are a lunatic. In the R&P, I've always been told: I love you, but your batsh*t crazy. The "I love you" part, combined with the respect you are given for being a reg, makes for enough warm fuzzies to keep you unscathed when you DO have to battle it out in there. I become a better person, and a better Christian, through my interactions in there.

Conversely, Ravelry brings out the worst in me each and every time. Why? Because Ravelry is nothing like a Cafe Philo. It's like a transgendered alternate lifestyle NOW liberal fest, where I feel, very often, totally alone. Everything I say and think is so utterly foreign to these women (and the occasional man that pops in) that I frequently am met with shock and awe.

Whatever other Christians are in there are painful silent, or they simply spend their time agreeing in the places they can with what they read to make friends, instead of challenging people to grow. Whenever we DO get some Christians in there who are willing to take a stand, they immediately get swarmed with so much BS and confusion and satanic doctrine that they quickly fold over themselves and retreat to pray and lick their wounds. One cannot even have a thread that lays out the basic tenets of Christianity without being literally swamped with lies, new age garbage, demonic doctrines, and "educated" information that negates Christ's Godhood, the Holy Trinity, or Satan's existence, and then you come out looking like a wierdo for actually believing the basic tenets of the Christian Faith. It is so disheartening. These people embrace all that is sad, heartbreaking, wrong, evil, immoral, and dark and earnestly believe it will enhance their human experience. It is painful to look at, but more importantly, it's painful to go in there and even remotely attempt to tear a hole in their dark bubble and let some light in. You are met with so much venom disguised as sugar that you come out of there literally gasping for peace. Talk about an exercise in futility.

It infuriates me to think that when I'm NOT posting in there, they just go through life, patting each other on the back for being such spectacularly TOLERANT human beings, so evolved, and they have no idea that there is a big wide world outside of their LYS and job at the food co-op (no offense, Jen, if you're reading) where the reality is that they are as deceived as they come. Of course, when I do post, it doesn't even make a dent in the crazy, and all it does is send alien lazer beams of angst and frustration aimed at my heart-- because deep down, as much as I can't stand their mindsets, I DO care about these people. And they are WILLINGLY giving themselves over to ALL that our Lord has warned us against.

In a way, I guess I can understand how much it pains the Father's heart to hear/see people believe these things. It draws me closer to the Lord. My evangelical response used to be to keep on going in there and shouting out the good news, but my Catholic response is to WEEP over ravelry and to "stiff upper lip" it, shut up, start praying and do penance for them.

Perhaps this lent I can offer up some part of my lenten fast for the salvation of the souls in Ravelry.... for the light to somehow penetrate this forum where participants aren't having "discussions" but rather willingly submitting to brainwashing and encouraging each other in the name of "tolerance" to take in ANYTHING they can get their hands on but godliness.

As a dear raveler said to me in an email yesterday:
"I’ve been reading the thread in DAR. They’re really quite hypocritical aren’t they? They’re remarkably tolerant until someone disagrees with them."

Amen to that!!! May the Lord create forums for personal discussion throughout the internet, where His name alone will be praised, and where the darkness flees like roaches from the light.

19 comments:

  1. i understand better now why rav is so frustrating for you. but hon. forums are not meant 2 revolve around YOU. you so frequently state that things revolve around YOU so i should have caught on earlier that because DAR is not "the barbie show" where you get this massive amount of respect simply for being there for so long, it has of course been bothering you. respect is more than periods of time, and you cannot force it. if yyou want/prefer a forum that is all about you and you are respected (which is what this blog is really all about) then please stay at r&p. but hon, dar was never about you - not even from day one.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nor did I ever think they were. However, as a poster, I should have the freedom to express myself without getting hammered, asked to explain myself, or asked to provide "proof" for my opinions. It's a free country, and I am allowed to go outside with a megaphone and tell passersby what I think. That isn't my intention in a forum, but if I want to do so, I certainly have that right. In Rav, that basic human right to freedom of speech and freedom of opinion is totally denied.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Also--- "you so frequently state that things revolve around YOU "

    Um, a bit harsh much? And when? I never ask for things to be about me, they just always end up that way in there.

    I don't care that I'm disrespected so much as that I'm simply not allowed to have an opinion if it isn't the norm. That's what's infuriating.

    ReplyDelete
  4. "I should have the freedom to express myself without getting hammered"

    We both know that's not what is going on. Perhaps that is your perspective, but it certainly is not what occurs. Honestly, when you regularly deteriorate your discussions about people's beliefs to include words like, "demonic" what exactly do you THINK is going to happen? (And not just, "I think this is demonic" - either JUST TO BE CLEAR). Perhaps people were being rude or hammering you years ago - but you've been online long enough to know how to behave, be polite, etc. You degrade those who DO know how to do this as less than Christian or people who are not even honest with themselves.

    Really? You've been inside their heads and know this for a fact? I doubt it.

    If you were without your Reg status on R&P - you'd easily be marked as a troll, because your behavior on Rav is exactly that. You start something, you're mean, and then you bail because people have the AUDACITY to speak up.

    You have the right to say whatever you want (inside the set rules of course) but people also have the RIGHT to question anything you assert as facts. They are NOT questioning your personal beliefs, anyone can see that, they are questioning your FACTS which are OFF. If you don't want people to question whether or not the sky is green, then don't post there. Boo-hoo.

    Finally, I don't think it's harsh to state something you have no qualms about yourself. "I never ask for things to be about me, they just always end up that way in there. " <-- YOU make it about you, maybe this isn't even conscious anymore, but you do. You go in, purposly stir the pot, purposly cause conflict, and then wonder why things become about you?

    If Rav brings out the worst in you, why are you still on? Just so YOU can tell the NOW LIBERALS what's up? So they know people think different than them. Uh, whatever happened to the people/posters who DO think differently than them and DO regularly post like say, Daybreak? There are totally great posters in that forum who post and post what they think.

    Things don't become about you because you are a Christian or a Catholic or because you are a conservative. Threads totally derail into hell in a hand basket because of your utter disrespect for other people, THEIR rights and freedoms, their beliefs, and common courtesy. That's why when you enter a thread, it becomes heated, etc.

    Finally, it's really telling that you have to go outside DAR to complain about things that occur IN DAR. Obviously, this is an issue that anyone who observes these regular threads is going to see right through. Otherwise, you would have worked this out in DAR - like you would in R&P. If you cannot handle the fire, stay out of the kitchen.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Take a deep breath. You sound extremely tired and bitchy.

    First, It's a blog. I get to say whatever I like. :)
    Second, I said the same thing in DAR-- the place is BS, just like BID before it and the general forum before IT. Ravelry is full of psychotic, creepy, people. And no, people like daybreak don't count because she buys the BS and the half she doesn't buy she just smiles about-- she doesn't care to actually stick her neck out there because she's pretty much the same as anyone else who posts in there, just a different flavor.
    Third, I DONT go in ravelry anymore. I went into that thread specifically because you asked me to check it out.

    In fact, I don't really do forums anymore because quite frankly, the demands of life have gotten to be too much for me to actually "put my money where my mouth is" AND continue to be a vocal advocate in the internets for a godly life. There comes a time when you have to shut down the laptop and just do it.

    The point that I think you are totally missing is that none of this, EVER, has been about me. Whether I'm rude or I'm kind, no matter what method or tactic I use, it's my IDEAS and the things I believe to be truth that threaten people in there, and the fact that I believe them, AS FACTS, that bothers you and everyone else. And quite honestly, I don't care. the only times I care is when, like tonight, I have to correct a faulty assumption that I'm either an attention whore or just plain crazy.
    I am a human being, who lives and breathes a totally different way than the world inside Ravelry, and if once in a while I want to remind them that they don't OWN the planet and they don't get to DETERMINE how it should be run, I have that right.
    And of all people, liberals should know that. What's disgusting is that liberals are more fascist than fascists ever were.

    ReplyDelete
  6. And I really should say that I'm certain you have better use of your time than harrassing me about my opinions on DAR... like homework, or hanging out with the fam.

    You are constantly seeking me out lately and bouncing into everything I write and say to stir up strife.... I certainly don't return the favor if you haven't noticed. There's ALOT I could say about your latest blogs or status updates that might rain on YOUR parade, but as a friend I certainly wouldn't dream of doing so-- I'd rather save my words for what will build up, edify, and encourage you in goodness.

    For what it's worth--- I think you're being extremely unstable in your approach to our relationship and it's disconcerting. We haven't talked in several days--so I'm fairly shocked that the first thing I hear from you is not an email update with how work is going and how the family is but rather a big, nasty finger pointing session where you give me a hard time for not sharing an opinion with you about how Ravelry operates. It hardly seems kind, let alone normal or fair. Just a thought. Goodnight, girl.

    You know I love you, I'm just saying. If you want to fight, I'm always here, but I'd much rather save my breath for our nicer conversations.

    ReplyDelete
  7. And again -- you turn it personal. "we're friends, so you shouldn't tell me when I'm out of line".

    I created DAR and honestly don't enjoy people spreading lies about the posters there. Barbie, the posters are not "threatened" by your beliefs, they are offended by your total rudeness and disrespect to them and their ideas. You force it to be about you - maybe you're more well behaved on R&P but I've had to review your posts in DAR and can confidently say - you MAKE it about you.

    If you're really off Rav, delete your profile. Put your money where your mouth is since you too busy to come in and cause strife anymore. :)

    The reason I'm posting this is simply because you're lying about what goes on in that group. If you care enough to blog about something as totally off as the posters in DAR and what occurs there, you should own up to it in DAR as well. Either these things really ARE happening and it's a legit discussion within DAR or it's not.

    If you don't want me, or anyone else, to call out and question things you write - then don't write them. There's a reason I rarely blog anymore. Either you're able to take someone questioning you or you are not.

    Your interpretation of what is going on in DAR is SO off. To put it in a way you probably will understand best - it's like Mormon doctrine to you.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I am NOT lying about what goes on in that group.
    Just like virtually every forum I have encountered on Ravelry, it is FULL of people who question the reality of God and Satan, who question authority, who question scripture, who question morality as it stands, who vocally oppose all that is good and right and stand for all that is creepy, nasty, and evil. And that isn't a lie, it's a fact.
    From abortion to the primacy of scripture and everything in between, the posters in DAR, as a whole, choose the wrong, and that's their prerogative. As I said, it's a free country, and I don't care if they want to do that. what I DO care about is that I am PERPETUALLY being silenced in ravelry for HAVING A DIFFERENT OPINION---- if I had the time i could go through hundreds of threads in DAR, in BID, and in the GENERALFORUM where I was as polite as they come-- drippingly sugary sweet, and where I was treated EXACTLY the same as I was when I was being snippy and facetious. It isn't about me, it's not about my presentation, it's about my ideas, which threaten people, and there is absolutely NOTHING you can show me that will convince me otherwise. I've gone back and read and re-read every train wreck of a DAR thread and wondered where did it go wrong,and I can honestly say that it really wasn't about me or my presentation. Whether I'm Kind and polite or I'm snippy with nasty undertones, I GET THE SAME REACTION. true story.

    I'm not ON rav for the forums. I use rav because I'm a knitter, and I like to be able to look up patterns, check how other people work on patterns I've got problems with, and get ideas for new projects. I will never delete my account because I think Ravelry is great for the knitting. It's not about the forums, the forums are just there....like an ugly sore reminding me that popular culture is really as bad as we sometimes joke it is.

    ReplyDelete
  9. The bottom line (after reading and re-reading your posts) is that I'm right... it IS about my ideas and not about me.

    I use words like "demonic" to describe demonic doctrines because they ARE.
    That's what I believe, know, and live.
    That's my "theology" and my "ideology" and my worldview. These are my ideas-- and I share them with billions of christians the world over.
    YOU don't want me to use words like that because you think they are "inflammatory" or "insensitive" but they are absolutely the correct words to use when we are discussing my beliefs or mindset.
    Thus, as I said, you (and everyone) accuse me of being rude, crazy, outlandish, etc. for simply sharing what I believe.
    WHen you're in a RELIGION FORUM, it is virtually impossible to avoid sharing what you believe.

    You certainly shouldn't hide it or water it down in order to make friends. In the R&P, my ideas about Islam, for example, have earned me every manner of accusation of being under the influence of djinn (muslim demons) for going against the "TRUE FAITH" of Islam. But at the end of the day, I can be friendly and on good terms with these muslims because at least they had the guts to say what they REALLY believed.

    Watered down Christians, however, are so decieved they even decieve THEMSELVES-- they don't like what I'm saying, but since they don't believe in evil outside of human evil, they blame it on mental illness or some other human fault and pat themselves on the back for being SOOOOO much "more" tolerant than I am, when the fact is, they ARE NOT tolerant of what THEY Percieve to be a threat--- JUST LIKE ME!

    At least I'm honest about it.

    ReplyDelete
  10. "True story", well iyou are right - it is a story, just not a true one. Before we start dragging some red herrings through here let's settle one topic at a time.

    The clear and provable evidence shows that people react to your strife - NOT to your ideas. I have reviewed your posts and 9/10 of them are angry, offensive (not because of ideas but because of the insults you throw at people), and ungodly. I see a bully who pitches a fit when questioned.

    I hate 2 break it to you, but DAR has rules and if you don't like them, too bad. These rules include common courtesy for others, being able to back up FACTS (not opinions - FACTS), and the like. The rules are not unreasonable, they are there for a reason. Yet you feel you are above the rules and continue to break them, run away when challenged, and then whine to the world about the mean people on Rav. Sure they are people who are not nice to you anymore, because you have proven yourself as unreliable and unkind (in Rav).

    I am so happy for you that you have found a church that finally makes you happy. You were so unhappy @ Manna that its no wonder you went looking for something familiar and safe. That's great. But in the years I have known you, I have seen you become more mean, rude, aragont, and prideful since your return to the Catholic church. When you first went back io was so angry AT the "friends" around who opposed your return. Perhaps they simply knew better than me. You have become a mean mean snob who steps on people like they are trash. Maybe your not like this with your Catholic friends but you have managed tpo mangle and alienate ever noncatholic friend who is not related to you. That says a lot.

    What does that have in common with DAR? Online you are a super star, a special person revered in the R&p, a "reg" but in dar you are an ordinary person who is mean to people. Who is offensive not just because you use the term "demonic" in an insulting wway, but because you actually insult people. You alienate everyone on dar not because of your ideas but because of how you treat them. Like trash, like they are beneath you. Once upon a time might have actually cared about these people, but now its about patting YOURSELF on the back for being a "threat" or being a "real Christian" and more.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I think you need to understand this: for real.

    I don't care about DAR. I don't particularly care about the people in DAR...obviously I wish them the best, but I don't have the slightest inclination to worry or stress out about how they choose to think or what they choose to do. YOU, I do. It bothers me greatly when I feel that you are walking away from God, but them, not so much-- I don't HAVE a relationship with them, they are not "real" people to me, they are simply internet people.

    You say that I have alienated every noncatholic friend I have, but I have to correct you. Many of them alienated THEMSELVES and will freely tell you that.. I was MORE than welcoming.

    And many of them, in the last year, have returned to the special place in my life that I had hoped they would once they realized I wasn't WALKING AWAY FROM GOD. They had a legitimate reason for fearing for their association with me. I respect that, even if I was hurt that it was wrong.

    If you will look at my facebook, you will see that it is FILLED TO THE BRIM with protestant friends who neither feel that I am alienating them nor feel that I am "mean," "judgemental," or "snobby."

    I am not those things in real life. Anyone (including you) who has met me for five seconds understands that I am the OPPOSITE of mean-- I'm lively, friendly, outgoing, and deeply compassionate.

    If I get to the end of my rope in DAR (and this has happened ONCE as far back as I can remember, in the submission thread) and lose my temper, then I am clearly not a perfect person. But you know what? For as much as I 've posted on rav and for as much BS as I've put up with, I've been MORE than patient, graceful and kind with people who treated me with far less than what I gave them in the ONE thread I lost my temper in.

    Honestly, whatever. I'm beyond over it, Amanda. I'm still pretty shocked that you think THIS is a better way to spend your time than anything else you could be doing. What do you hope to accomplish with these comments? You want me to tell you that I'm a mean, rude, obnoxious uncompassionate person who doesn't understand how to treat other people's beliefs with respect? Anyone who knows me knows that isn't the case. I get enough PMs in rav from people who agree with me that I'm not treated correctly in there to know that it's not all my imagination.

    And if I want to come to my PERSONAL BLOG and rant about my frustrations, and vent, rather than calling someone and gossiping or sinning in anger by continuing to post in there, then hey, that's my perogative. As for me, I've already wasted FAR too much time on this pathetic state of affairs.

    ReplyDelete
  12. And I forgot to say one last thing:

    You say that the rules in DAR state that we must be able to back up facts with data. (I've never read the rules, so I don't know that they do or that they don't.)

    In the discussion of religion, FACTS are what we make them.
    God exists and is real. He is a trinity. Sin is bad for the soul. These are FACTS,that cannot be proven outside the realm OF theology-- there is no methodology in existence that measures the truthfulness of these "facts." This is why we say that we have faith. To ask someone to back these things up with scientific proof in a discussion about faith is absolutely LUDICROUS. It is an impossibility. It is a worthless waste of time that would be spent better giving witness to the REASONS behind the belief or idea.
    This is why I find it infuriating to be asked to "back up" my opinions.
    I am not interested in reading science papers and hearing doctor's quotes. If I was, I wouldn't be talking to people, I'd be sitting at Barnes and Noble with my nose in the American Journal of Science. What poeple who go into forums want is to communicate with others about life's experiences, to somehow connect and be given food for thought and the opportunity to make a difference somehow. Think about that the next time you ask someone for "facts" and "backup data."

    ReplyDelete
  13. I was just posting this song on facebook and it reminded me that this song describes EXACTLY how I feel about the world, particularly about the world of DAR. THIS is what I wish for the people of DAR-- for myself, for my family, for the whole world... THIS:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ADyLxkZRATQ

    how you can get from THAT to I'm mean and judgemental-- I just don't know.

    ReplyDelete
  14. “I think you need to understand this: for real.”
    I do understand, you just don’t like it.



    “I don't care about DAR. I don't particularly care about the people in DAR”
    That is very apparent – both here and in the manner in which you treat the posters within DAR. This isn’t news to me.



    “It bothers me greatly when I feel that you are walking away from God”
    Let’s not change the subject to another opinion of yours that has zero to do with your poor (to put it mildly) behavior on the board.



    “Many of them alienated THEMSELVES”
    I’m sure some of them have. But certainly not all of them, and your attitude towards Protestants since returning to the Catholic church certainly isn’t helpful.



    “neither feel that I am alienating them nor feel that I am "mean," "judgemental," or "snobby."”
    Their lack of recognition of your behavior does not mean that you are not being snobby or judgmental.



    “I am not those things in real life.”
    You’re partly right – you were never this bad before in real life.



    “I've been MORE than patient, graceful and kind with people who treated me with far less than what I gave them in the ONE thread I lost my temper in.”
    More than one, and I’d disagree.



    “And if I want to come to my PERSONAL BLOG and rant about my frustrations, and vent, rather than calling someone and gossiping or sinning in anger by continuing to post in there”
    I don’t really see a difference. But I understand your NEED to JUSTIFY your actions. That is understandable. However, call a spade a spade – you are looking for vengeance if only for your readers to think that the posters in DAR are ungodly, ill behaved, mean, Christian hating people. Which they are NOT.



    “In the discussion of religion, FACTS are what we make them.”
    Somewhat true. To a point. Obviously there is history, obviously there are scholars who say x,y, and z and a,b, and c. However you were not asserting facts, your were asserting your opinions DRESSED UP as facts. For example, Martin Luther was demonic. Not a fact, an OPINION.



    “This is why we say that we have faith. To ask someone to back these things up with scientific proof in a discussion about faith is absolutely LUDICROUS.”
    No one demanded scientific proof for anything, acquire better reading skills. Pay attention, and stop looking for your turn to rant instead of actually understanding what people are saying/requesting.



    “This is why I find it infuriating to be asked to "back up" my opinions.”
    Let’s be honest, it upsets you because people QUESTION you and then you can’t just be a troll.



    “I am not interested in reading science papers and hearing doctor's quotes. If I was, I wouldn't be talking to people, I'd be sitting at Barnes and Noble with my nose in the American Journal of Science.”
    As usual, not listening. I cannot remember the last time you listened – REALLY listened.



    “What poeple who go into forums want is to communicate with others about life's experiences, to somehow connect and be given food for thought and the opportunity to make a difference somehow.”
    Because you represent every poster. I forgot. My mistake.





    Here’s the bottom line Barbie – you want to rant about DAR, that’s your right to do so. No one is stopping you. However, it’s also my right to call you out and say – “Hey this isn’t right! These are lies and exaggerations.” Again, if you don’t want people to call you out when you’re wrong, then don’t post it online. End of story.
    If you want to play this game, degrade the posters in this group, and continue to troll the group – then know that you’ll be unwelcome and I’ll personally delete every single one of your posts. Either play by the rules, or you don’t get to play. And that is that.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Anyone who reads DAR regularly, is of course, free to come to their own conclusions. I personally don't know a single Christian IRL , protestant OR Catholic, who wouldn't bristle at the utter PELOSI (that's BS for you non St Pat's people) that gets spouted in there regularly masquerading as Christianity.

    As for facts vs opinions, if Martin Luther did, indeed, have a demonic issue (and both HE-- read his works--- and I believe he did) then hey, that's a fact, not an opinion.

    As for not being allowed to post in DAR anymore... let me just say: OH, BOO HOO.

    ReplyDelete
  16. That's the thing about facts hon, viewable and accesable to all regardless of opinions. Great that we both agree on that.

    And since you are yet again demonstrating a lack of listening - I didn't say you could no long post on DAR, I said if you continue to break set rules THEN you will no longer be able to post on DAR.

    Have a great day! :)

    ReplyDelete
  17. No, I definitely heard you, and I'm still saying: Oh, boo hoo. We're called to be IN the world but not OF the world, and wasting time posting in DAR when I'm a busy mom and wife is definitely OF the world.

    Which is what this blog was about--- the fact that it is utterly fruitless for a Christian to spend time in there, a fact which has been proven time and again by the fact that out of millions of Christian knitters around the world who agree with me on these issues I'm the only one who wasted any time arguing in there. I got a lot of emails telling me I was wasting my time, but I didn't think I was. Now I see it.

    I'm clearly the slowest Christian on the planet-- It took me until I wrote that blog to REALLY figure that out... there can be no fruit in there because virtually every soul in there has CHOSEN to be where they are at and have placed those blinders on themselves nice and tight... most of them heard the truth a long time ago and walked away from it as fast as they could.

    You can play the "you're mean" card all you want, but at the end of the day, the fact is that JUST like BID and the GENERAL Forum, you guys have managed to isolate yourselves from anything that makes you uncomfortable and doesn't line up with your comfy little worldview in which everyone is saved and there is no good and evil.

    Thus, you will continue to pat yourselves on the back for being SO tolerant and peaceful all the while acting like nazis whenever someone who doesn't fit your little mold comes in and says something you don't agree with, and rapidly push them out so you can continue to babble incoherently about your emotional conceptions of reality.

    You keep telling me I'm lying, but you are lying to yourselves. My own sin here is that I honestly have a hard time praying for people who are that willingly moronic.

    ReplyDelete
  18. “No, I definitely heard you”
    Great, then you can stop exaggerating that you cannot post there anymore. So if you start saying it again, I will know that you are purposely lying.


    “the fact that it is utterly fruitless for a Christian to spend time in there”
    Depends on your goals – since they are to make Barbie clones, then I’d have to agree. Thank God it’s a fruitless endeavor.


    “fact which has been proven time and again by the fact that out of millions of Christian knitters around the world who agree with me”
    Not a fact – unless you have statistical proof. (<- Which is not SCIENCE by the way, just to help you out there.) :)


    ”there can be no fruit in there because virtually every soul in there has CHOSEN to be where they are”
    Yet another example of your purposeful lack of understanding OR compassion. Of course, you live in la-la Barbie land where everything is Barbie-centric, so I suppose it’s understandable.



    most of them heard the truth a long time ago and walked away from it as fast as they could.
    You don’t know that and you certainly cannot speak for their relationships with God. When did you BECOME God?



    ”You can play the "you're mean" card all you want, but at the end of the day, the fact is that JUST like BID and the GENERAL Forum, you guys have managed to isolate yourselves from anything that makes you uncomfortable”
    You can play that card all you want, but that certainly doesn’t make it a fact. The fact is you are a bitch to everyone in there, treat them like trash because they’re not Catholics, and then whine to the world about those “mean” posters. Which ARE lies.



    ”Thus, you will continue to pat yourselves on the back”
    Actually, what this blog (and others) is patting yourself on the back and showing off how godly you are. “I’m so good! I’m so patient! I put up with a lot!”



    ”while acting like Nazis”
    Not true. But you ground everything in your skewed sense of reality and then stir in your uber emotional states and of course, this is what you would get. Ever hear the phrase, “Shit rolls downhill..” that means it starts somewhere and honey, it doesn’t take too much looking to find where.



    “rapidly push them out”
    Not true. Two great examples are Ladydove and Daybreak – both of which are vocal about their beliefs.



    You keep telling me I'm lying”
    Because you are.



    ”but you are lying to yourselves”
    Because you live inside me (like Jesus) and know this for a fact. I keep forgetting these things! Silly me! :P


    ”My own sin here is that I honestly have a hard time praying for people who are that willingly moronic
    You can add to that wrath and pride.


    ReplyDelete
  19. At this point, I really can only assume that you are perpetuating the conversation because you are enjoying this rather than trying to make a point, since you so obstinately refuse to relinquish your obsession with telling me day and night that I'm mean to people and uncompassionate.

    I've noticed that in the last several months as your interests have waned from caring for your family and serving God and the Church to pit bulls, fitness, vampires, and work that you have progressively become more and more aggressive about sharing your religious and political beliefs.

    I have a friend who is desperately AP as a parent. You know me well, and you know that that is my idea of a parenting nightmare. And yet we manage to maintain a close friendship because i don't tell her what I think about her parenting, she doesn't tell me what she thinks about mine, and when it comes up, we gloss over the issue and we move on to other things. That's being polite. You, on the other hand, have been persistently calling on me to talk -- no, debate--- about everything from abortion to gay rights to theology to feminism DESPITE the fact that you know exactly how I feel about these topics-- it's like something in you just wants to poke at me and see what I'll do.

    I haven't changed, I'm still happy to provide a very verbal, very vocal reason for why I believe what I do. However, I really don't understand, neither as a friend nor as one "compassionate human being" to another, what the purpose of these little exercises are.

    I'm the one whose been diagnosed with Borderline, not you, so it seems VERY strangely symptomatic to me that you keep seeking me out to hound me about things and then get ruffled when I react. Not to mention that there is no reason in the world why you would WANT to argue about these things with me.

    When you were a die hard mormon, I didn't spend all day long griping at you about staying mormon, I spent the time finding things we DID agree on and building from there. Nowadays all you're interested in is deconstructing MY beliefs and poking at my principles to see if you can find weak spots, not to mention telling me that you think I'm "mean," "a bitch," "rude," "prideful" and "wrathful."

    Your favorite bible verse used to be Colossians 4:6
    "Let your speech always be with grace, as though seasoned with salt, so that you will know how you should respond to each person."

    Maybe if you meditated on it more, the way to tell me what you're trying to say would have been to say:

    "Hey Barbie, this post really hurts my feelings because I think it misrepresents DAR, and because I don't think that you really care about any of the people in there. I'm afraid that as a mod, I'm going to have to ask you to stick to the rules if you keep posting in there."

    I still would have disagreed, but at least now I wouldn't be sitting here irritated with you. Just something to think about.

    ReplyDelete

Thank you so much for your comments! I look forward to hearing from you.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...